Analysts Warn of ‘Damaging Backlash’ If Congress Imposes Trucks-Only Mileage Tax

Washington D.C. – Transportation analysts testifying at a U.S. Senate committee hearing this week warned lawmakers that imposing a federal trucks-only mileage-based tax would set off a “damaging backlash.”

Right now on Capitol Hill, lawmakers are considering proposals to impose a vehicle-miles-traveled (VMT) tax on passenger vehicles and commercial motor vehicles as part of legislation to reauthorize funding for federal highway programs.


One proposal supported by a bi-partisan group of legislators calls for imposing a trucks-only tax.

The trucks-only tax has been studied by the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO).

According to the CBO, a VMT tax on all commercial trucks with load ratings of over 10,000 pounds would raise $2.6 billion per penny of tax per vehicle-mile, while a narrower VMT tax limited to tractor-trailers (26,000+ pounds) would raise $1.6 billion per penny of tax per vehicle-mile.

During a U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works hearing on Wednesday, numerous transportation researchers urged members against including a trucks-only VMT tax into the upcoming highway funding bill.

“I would like to caution very seriously singling out the trucking industry to be the place to start,” said Robert Pool, transportation director at the Reason Foundation. “The worst thing policy could do is to single them out… because that would create a backlash that I think could be very damaging.”


Dr. Patricia Hendren, executive director of the Eastern Transportation Coalition, and supporter of moving to a VMT tax for all vehicles, echoed Pool’s warning.

“As heavy users of our interstate transportation system, we really need to look at our trucking industry separately than our passenger vehicles,” she said. “I’m concerned that if we move forward with a user-based approach it does need to address all users versus singling out one of our users.”

Supporters of a trucks-only VMT tax often argue it would be simpler to implement and collect taxes from commercial trucks than from passenger vehicles.


Pool challenged those assertions.

It’s really, as their findings have found, it’s more complex in a lot of ways than passenger cars,” he said referring to a recently released report by the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI). 

Congress Eyeing ‘Transformational’ Vehicle-Miles-Traveled Tax in Upcoming Highway Bill
Speed Limiter Mandate, Insurance Hike And More Expected To Be In Upcoming Highway Bill
After Backlash, USDOT Says Taxing Drivers By The Mile NOT Part of Infrastructure Bill But…
Democrats Score Big Win in Fight to Pass Bill Trucking Groups Warn Will Wipe Out Many I/Cs

Proponents of a trucks-only tax also contend the trucking industry doesn’t pay its fair share relative to the damage heavy trucks cause to America’s roads and bridges.

According to ATRI though, the trucking industry contributes roughly 45% of net total tax revenues into the Highway Trust Fund (HTF) when adding up tax receipts from federal diesel fuel purchases, the heavy vehicle use tax (HVUT), International Fuel Tax Agreement (IFTA) taxes, and the 12% federal excise tax (FET) on purchases of new equipment.


Last month, the Owner Operator Independent Driver’s Association (OOIDA) sent a letter to lawmakers calling the notion trucking is not paying its fair share “preposterous” and urging them to drop the trucks-only VMT tax idea.

“We are disappointed that this controversial and discriminatory proposal has resurfaced, as our industry has consistently supported increasing HTF revenue through equitable increases to existing user fees,” wrote Todd Spencer, OOIDA president and CEO. “The inclusion of such a divisive policy in the next surface transportation reauthorization would instantly eliminate our support for the bill and likely destroy any hope for its passage.”

This will be an issue to watch in the coming weeks and will be tracking it closely.

Photo courtesy

If you enjoyed this article, please help us grow by sharing it. Thank you!

Comment (2)

  1. Proponents of a trucks-only tax also contend the trucking industry doesn’t pay its fair share relative to the damage heavy trucks cause to America’s roads and bridges.

    There is the 4 word phrase to introduce and enact a new tax. “pay it’s fair share”. Please show us where trucks and trucking don’t pay it’s fair share.

    Perhaps if you elitist would quit robbing from the tax payers to enrichen your thieving selves there would be money.

  2. Pretty soon, there will be fewer and fewer trucks out here to tax… Then what? Hopefully, this is my last year, pulling the plug on this BS, they can have it.


Pin It on Pinterest

Share This