Trailer Manufacturer Hit With $18.9M Judgement in “Wrongful Death” Side Underride Suit

Santa Fe, NM – A Santa Fe jury slapped Utility Trailer Manufacturing Co. (UTM) with an $18.9 million judgement after it found the company was partially negligent in the November 2015 crash death of a 16-year-old high school student.

On November 13, 2015, Riley Hein was traveling westbound in the right lane along I-40 through Tijeras Canyon when a tractor-trailer operating beside him veered into his lane.

As the two vehicles negotiated a corner, Hein’s Honda passenger vehicle became wedged underneath the UTM semi-trailer.

According to investigators, Hein’s vehicle was dragged approximately a half-mile and scraped along a concrete barrier before the Honda burst into flames.


Hein reportedly suffered burns over 75% of his body and was declared dead on the scene.

In June 2016, Hein’s parents, Eric and Wendy, filed a wrongful death suit naming Choptank Transport, GNB Trucking, Barkandhi Express and the New Mexico Department of Transportation as defendants.

The Heins would later settle privately with each of the above named defendants, but the family filed a second amended complaint September 18, 2017, naming UTM as a defendant.

The suit alleged the company sold a “dangerous and defective product” that contributed to Riley’s death because it was not equipped with side underride guards.

The Heins argued that a side underride guard could have saved Riley’s life and therefore UTM was at least partially negligent.


UTM contended the company is under no such requirement to sell its trailers equipped with side underride guards.

Further, the trailer manufacturer asserted it has not been proven that side underride guards would have prevented Riley’s death.

Additionally, the company argued side impact guards have not been shown to be “technologically or economically feasible.”


Immigrant Truckers Who Don’t Know Much English Are Being Cheated, Lawsuit Alleges

$31 MILLION MaxxForce Engine Fraud Judgement REVERSED

Trucking Group Continues Fight For ELD Exemption Accusing FMCSA of “Fraud”

Lawsuits Flying Against Trucking Co. in Wake of Fiery Crash That Left 7 Dead

After a two-week trial, the jury found that UTM and the truck driver, who was no longer a party in the suit, were negligent in Riley’s death.

The verdict assessed damages of $42 million – $38 million to his Riley’s estate and $2 million each for Eric and Wendy for loss of consortium.


Further, the jury apportioned the truck driver with 55% of the blame, while UTM was deemed to be 45% responsible.

Since the driver was not a defendant, his share won’t be paid.

However, UTM’s portion is $18.9 million.

Following the verdict, Mike Sievers, attorney for the family, said the Heins hope the jury’s decision “sends a message” to semi-trailer manufacturers to address the issue.

“They wanted a verdict to tell the industry they need to do something about this problem,” he was quoted by the Albuquerque Journal as saying.


Heins Are Pushing For Passage of Stop Underrides Act

Since Riley’s death, the Heins have become safety activists pushing for the requirement that side underride guards be mandated on all heavy duty commercial big rigs.

The couple has been lobbying for the passage of recently re-introduced bi-partisan legislation authored by Sens. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) and Marco Rubio (R-FL) called the “Stop Underrides Act” (S.665).

U.S. Reps. Steven Cohen (D-TN) and Mark DeSaulnier (D-CA) introduced HR1511 into the U.S. House of Representatives mirroring the Senate bill.

Trucking industry groups such as the American Trucking Associations and the Owner Operator Independent Driver’s Association have been fierce critics of the new push to mandate side underride guards.


READ more about the push to mandate side underride guards HERE.



If you enjoyed this article, please help us grow by sharing it. Thank you!

Comment (1)

  1. I’m a father of a teenager and I can understand that the parents are upset but this BS is completely out of control in this country and trucking industry is gonna have to shut down this country to get the government to step in because of these ambulance chasing scum of the earth attorneys that sue for millions and millions of dollars for anything that happens that is related to trucking because the government let’s these scumbag attorneys steal millions and millions of dollars at a time for something that if it was another car involved in the accident they would only be going after 1/75 the amount!!!!! And I hope utility trailer wins this lawsuit and counter Sue’s them because there is absolutely NO law in the United States that require anybody to install underride system on a trailer. Those wind deflectors shown wouldn’t stop anything from going under the trailer!! You can kick those and break them because they are only designed for aerodynamics not stopping cars from going under the trailer.


Pin It on Pinterest

Share This